Contribution Tool

TFSA or RRSP: which first?

Answer a few questions about your income and goals. Get a clear breakdown of which account to prioritise for tax efficiency, based on your actual numbers, not a blanket rule.

The TFSA vs RRSP question has no universal answer. It depends on your income today versus what you expect in retirement. The RRSP gives you a bigger tax refund the higher your income, but you'll pay tax on withdrawals later. The TFSA grows and withdraws completely tax-free. This tool runs the numbers for your specific situation: income, province, and marginal rate, and shows you which account is likely more tax-efficient over time. Always worth discussing with a financial advisor before making a decision.

🛠 Dev
Your knowledge level
1
Your situation
$
Your total income before taxes. The number on your offer letter or T4.
Gross employment income (before any deductions)
Your current age. Affects how many years your investments can grow.
2
Home buying
Have you never owned a home, or not owned one in the last 4 years?
3
Additional details
Affects whether it's better to build RRSP room now or later
If yes, always max the match first. It's an instant 100% return
High retirement income makes RRSP withdrawals less attractive (taxed at high rates)
3
Projection settings
$
How much you're planning to put away each month.
Your personalised recommendation
Factor
TFSA
RRSP
Contributions
After-tax dollars No immediate tax break. You contribute money you've already paid tax on.
Pre-tax dollars You get a deduction that reduces your taxable income and generates a refund.
Withdrawals
Tax-free, any time Withdraw whenever you want with no tax owing. Room is restored the following January.
Taxed as income Withdrawals count as income in the year you take them. Room is not restored.
Government benefits impact
No impact TFSA withdrawals don't affect OAS, GIS, or income-tested benefits. ✓ Better
Counts as income RRSP/RRIF withdrawals can reduce OAS and GIS in retirement.
Best for your income
Flexibility
Very flexible No age limit, no mandatory conversion. Withdraw for any reason with no penalty. ✓ Better
Locked toward retirement Must convert to RRIF by age 71. Early withdrawals are taxed (and room is lost).

Projected growth over 20 years

Based on your monthly contribution amount.
Invested (~8% avg annual return)
Just saved (~3.5% HISA, no market risk)
Put the invested amount inside your TFSA or RRSP. A registered account removes tax on gains and withdrawals.

Canadian context

How this tool works

01

Your numbers, not averages

The recommendation is based on your income, province, age, and goals. Not a generic income bracket rule.

02

Tax efficiency, not investment advice

This tool helps you decide which account to contribute to first. What you invest in inside those accounts is a separate decision.

03

2026 tax rates

All calculations use confirmed 2026 federal and provincial brackets, including the Ontario surtax where applicable.

🔗
Put the account decision to work
Now that you know which account to prioritize, use the FIRE Calculator to see how your investments grow toward financial independence — with TFSA, RRSP, and CPP all factored in. Or use the Budget Calculator to find how much you can actually invest each month.

How these accounts work

01 / The TFSA

Invest after-tax dollars, pay zero tax on growth or withdrawals

You contribute money you've already paid tax on. Inside the account, every dollar compounds tax-free — dividends, capital gains, interest, all of it. Withdrawals are tax-free and don't count as income. In 2026 the annual limit is $7,000, with cumulative room up to $95,000 if you've never contributed since age 18.

02 / The RRSP

Contribute pre-tax dollars, defer the tax bill until withdrawal

RRSP contributions reduce your taxable income today — you get a refund at your marginal rate. Inside the account, growth is tax-sheltered. But withdrawals are fully taxable as income. The tax advantage is largest when you contribute in a high-income year and withdraw in a lower-income year (e.g. early retirement before CPP/OAS).

03 / The decision

It comes down to your tax rate now vs your tax rate in retirement

If your income is lower now (under ~$55K), TFSA first — the RRSP deduction isn't worth much and withdrawals later could push you into higher brackets. If you're in a high bracket now (over ~$100K) and expect lower income in retirement, RRSP gives the largest upfront tax refund. Most Canadians should use both.

04 / The FHSA

For first-time homebuyers: the best of both worlds

The First Home Savings Account (FHSA) gives you an RRSP-style deduction on contributions and TFSA-style tax-free withdrawals for a qualifying home purchase. Up to $8,000/year, $40,000 lifetime. If you're a first-time buyer, maxing your FHSA before either TFSA or RRSP is often the highest-value move.

Try our other tools
Budget tool
Zero-Based Budget Calculator
Give every dollar a job. Build a complete monthly budget with Canadian benchmarks.
Explore →
Calculator
Lifestyle Inflation Calculator
Got a raise but feel no richer? See exactly what lifestyle creep is costing your TFSA.
Explore →
Calculator
Emergency Fund Calculator
Find out exactly how much you need based on your expenses, employment type, and whether you have dependants.
Explore →
Calculator
FIRE & Coast FIRE Calculator
Decided which account to use? Now find your FIRE number — with CPP, OAS, tax gross-up, and a year-by-year withdrawal plan.
Explore →
* This tool is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Projections assume 8% average annual nominal return (broad index fund approximation) and are not guaranteed. TFSA, RRSP, and FHSA contribution limits apply. Verify your personal room via CRA My Account. Tax calculations use 2026 published federal and provincial brackets including individual provincial basic personal amounts and Ontario surtax. RRSP deduction room depends on your prior-year earned income (18% of prior year's earned income, up to the annual limit of $32,490 for 2026). Consult a registered financial advisor (CFP) before making significant financial decisions. Referral links on this page may earn a commission if you sign up, at no additional cost to you.